How did the Government of India Act, 1935 mark a point of no return in the history of constitutional development in India? (12 MARKS)(GS1) (UPSC 2006)
The Government of India Act, 1935, indeed marked a pivotal point in India's constitutional development, heralding significant changes that were instrumental in shaping the course of governance and politics in the country. This Act, while not fully implemented due to the onset of World War II and subsequent events, represented a definitive step towards a more structured and representative form of governance, thereby serving as a point of no return in India's constitutional journey
Federal Structure: Introducing Federal System in British India
Proposal for a federal structure comprising provinces and princely states.
Provinces to have elected legislatures and executive councils.
Princely states given the choice to join or stay outside the federation.
Division of Powers: Central and Provincial Governance
Legislative powers divided between central and provincial governments.
Central government retains control over defence, foreign affairs, and communications.
Provinces granted autonomy in areas like health, education, and local governance.
Empowering Provinces - Rise of Provincial Autonomy
Introduction of provincial autonomy with elected legislatures and responsible governments.
Abolishment of dyarchy, empowering governors as constitutional heads with limited authority.
Provinces given legislative and administrative powers, boosting Indian political influence locally.
Bicameral Central Legislature and Limited Powers
Establishment of bicameral central legislature - Federal Assembly and Council of States.
Federal Assembly (lower house) with elected members; Council of States (upper house) with nominated and elected members.
Central legislature's powers limited, with Governor-General holding veto authority
Central Authority and Special Powers in Governance: Reserved Subjects and Governor-General’s Role
Reservation of subjects such as defence and external affairs for the central government.
Governor-General empowered to intervene in provincial matters during crises, with residuary powers
Empowering India: Impact on Self-Governance
Significant step towards limited self-governance for India.
Framework for political development and increased Indian participation in governance.
Contribution to the growth of political parties and democratic processes through elections under Act provisions.
In conclusion, the Government of India Act, 1935, marked a point of no return in India's constitutional development due to its introduction of federal features, grant of provincial autonomy, establishment of bicameral legislatures, abolition of dyarchy, creation of the Federal Court, provisions for Public Service Commissions, and framework for a Constituent Assembly. These provisions laid the foundation for subsequent constitutional discussions and reforms, shaping the trajectory of governance and democracy in India.
One thought on “Constitutional development in India”
Really helpful answer. Thanks to team, Namma KPSC.
Really helpful answer. Thanks to team, Namma KPSC.