FRATERNITY
“Fraternity is the moral foundation of the Indian Constitution and essential for sustaining democracy in a diverse society.” Examine the constitutional provisions promoting fraternity in India. Discuss the challenges to its realization and suggest measures to strengthen constitutional fraternity.
Model Answer
Answer
- Fraternity is one of the core ideals enshrined in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution, aiming to secure the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation.
- Unlike liberty and equality, fraternity cannot be imposed through law alone; it requires social acceptance and mutual respect among citizens.
Constitutional Provisions Promoting Fraternity
- Preamble: Explicitly commits to promoting fraternity to ensure individual dignity and national unity.
- Single Citizenship (Part II): Fosters a common national identity across states and regions.
- Articles 14–18: Guarantee equality before law, prohibit discrimination, abolish untouchability, and remove social hierarchies.
- Article 25: Protects freedom of conscience and religion, encouraging inter-faith coexistence.
- Article 38: Directs the State to reduce inequalities and promote social, economic, and political justice.
- Article 39A: Ensures equal access to justice through free legal aid.
- Article 51A(e): Makes it a fundamental duty to promote harmony and common brotherhood and renounce practices derogatory to women.
Challenges to Fraternity
- Rising hate speech, communal polarization, and declining social trust.
- Persistent caste-based discrimination and atrocities against marginalized
- Growing economic inequality, creating social resentment and exclusion.
- Regionalism and nativism, including demands for local job reservations.
- Misuse of social media leading to misinformation and social divisions.
Measures to Strengthen Fraternity
- Promote constitutional values through education and civic awareness.
- Strengthen enforcement against hate crimes and discriminatory practices.
- Reduce socio-economic inequalities through inclusive development.
- Encourage inter-community dialogue and cultural exchanges.
- Ensure responsible conduct by public officials and political leaders.
Conclusion
As emphasized in judgments such as Tehseen Poonawalla v. Union of India and Kaushal Kishor v. State of Uttar Pradesh, fraternity is indispensable for preserving India's pluralistic democracy. Strengthening fraternity is essential for transforming constitutional ideals into social reality and ensuring national unity amidst diversity